CO129-072 - Indviduals - 1858 — Page 78

ac

The in_ by a clove analysis, _ that none of the (minetion) "Changer" "Haganest W. Wald we have been substantially

of them me repented to have

proved, and that many "ween brought on insufficient granels !

Stiver

Commissioners

primers ashu,

It is a fallacy to consider the decision of the saulpation of Mr. Caldwell' My first proposition has been established

Report;-

from their

Mira

and a mere citation of the

Canguage of some of it's findings the jilutide of my second.

will_demonstrate_

With regard to Charge bit, they sory, a longand uitinate convection between Wr. Caldwell and Mates fiscerating

of any

Caldwell's

Clino wong has been proved, but that there is no proof int

Connection by affinity according to Clunere dow

a custom.

July

Id: Id:

id. p. 95.

Y 24th May

ins Minutes of 58.

the 14 p.go.

"With regard to charge leven, it is proved that prices t

Diverediting

Lowell's day's Muintes of cry the 14 4858.7

Fiscrediting Caldwell's di

// baldwell has been in the habit, on Michelino= I wong's insupported information, of arresting persons, to his confreating. but that there is no loidence aus " or restoring property.

1 As to charge Mine, it has been proved that M. Galdwell anded in the acceptance of the Kaishich former sewant, ou bail, for Meabetions_wong, and that bra hai had been imprisoned for debt for few days for a thint time previously?

With reference to Charge eleven, a partnerships, ' with Mated ten-wong in a locha is proved, andy "fact, admitted by M. Caldwell; but that there is 110

to payments

Cvidence

ag

a

the

sunites of Juce of the Prairy 1858.

8.92 196.

July. J .91 ferie fr. A.

crediting

Tanto Work w Minutes of of the 14 the off

cuts to Mr. Caldwell out of the 1858. Life 9

" froduce of plunder made at Sea-

release of the

cut in

CLAS

of the discreting

of the fact stated in Charge Hurteen

- upon the Caldwell's representation

Vous to their Climacter, there is

IN AD

Cartorell's de

no doubt whatever. And s

th

ignorant

it appears incomprehensible to any heavon with 'M. Caldwell's Knowledge of the Chinese language, ins holding the appointment he did, nito habe bleu

out of the Clicu meter of the boats in which the Tmen were seized, and that one at least of these mea was a notorious pirate, particularly as it is in-

lvidence that Makeli the boats.

corosong

been

was Connected with.

Witte regard to Charge One, it being only

"matter of inference, _ we find in tu

as a

a frum of th

a

fied in support of suck reference, that a fan hef gratitude to Mr. Caldast.

wows offered by. as a mark of Caldwell.

W a " for being instrumental in the release of a Porchia - seined by furates, in which the man's for ther was, "but that this money was refused by M.Caldwell, I and on such refuval that it wows offered to Mrs. "Caldwell; a suojority however of the Commission 'do not feel satisfied that Mrs Buldwett accepted It has also been proved that a Clinese oney "female homed Maplok, who has been in pregnent "Communication with M. Galdwell (and is te forted 'but not proved to be a sister by Chinese usage of My bald well) received from the Tho Tiri pawn shop the sum of $ 400, because the sentence on a pronon

t -broker belonging to the said shop had been suition Approved therough her influence; and theat the received a further sum of $50 for her fursonat trouble in the matter. Further, snice the commence - ment of their Jugning M. Caldwell hears, solely upon the information Conveyed in

Anonymous letter, "that certain property had been Holeh, pormally

and without the assistance of the Police, planched

· Room in the rccupation of

recupation of Devour the Police (

a

ou say

an

Count

B

C

'D